Food & Drink

Milwaukee’s Heavenly Hoagies: 14 Italian Delight Destinations!

If you're a fan of sandwiches, you're in the right place. Milwaukee is home to some of the best Italian hoagies around.

With so many options to choose from, it's hard to know where to start. Whether you're a native Milwaukeean or just visiting, this guide will help you find the best Italian hoagies in the city.

What makes a great Italian hoagie? It's all about the ingredients. The bread must be fresh and slightly crusty, yet soft enough to absorb the flavors of the filling.

The filling should be a perfect balance of meats, cheese, and vegetables. From the salty cured meats to the tangy pickled veggies, every ingredient plays a crucial role in creating the perfect Italian hoagie.

Milwaukee has a thriving food scene, and the Italian hoagie is no exception. From classic delis to trendy cafes, there's an Italian hoagie for every taste and budget.

So, whether you're in the mood for a traditional hoagie or something with a modern twist, this guide has got you covered. Get ready to sink your teeth into the best Italian hoagies that Milwaukee has to offer.

1. Santino's Little Italy

Santino's Little Italy
352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Santino's Little Italy is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Italian hoagies. Their homemade meatballs and fresh-baked cookies are a testament to traditional Italian cooking.

The restaurant's staff is warm and welcoming, making the dining experience even more enjoyable.

The thin-crust pizzas are cooked to perfection in an 800-degree oven, and the fried calamari is a delicious appetizer. The restaurant is a great place for a date night or to celebrate a special occasion.

Reservations are recommended, as the restaurant can get quite busy. Santino's Little Italy transports diners to an old-school Italian eatery with its rustic setting and traditional Neapolitan pizzas.

2. Tenuta's Italian Restaurant

Tenuta's Italian Restaurant
2995 S Clement Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Tenuta's Italian Restaurant offers some of the best Italian hoagies in town.

The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it a great place to enjoy a delicious sandwich.

The homemade bread and fresh ingredients make their hoagies stand out from the rest.

They also offer a variety of other Italian dishes that are worth trying. Be sure to make a reservation as it can get busy.

3. Fixture Pizza Pub

Fixture Pizza Pub
623 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204 (Google Maps)

Fixture Pizza Pub is a charming bistro that serves up delicious Italian hoagies.

With exposed brick and a cozy tavern atmosphere, this place is perfect for a casual lunch or dinner.

Aside from their signature pizzas, they offer a nice selection of Italian subs and pastas.

The wait staff is friendly and attentive, and the local beer selection is top-notch. If you're looking for a tasty Italian hoagie, Fixture Pizza Pub is definitely worth a visit.

4. Martino's Italian Beef and Hot Dogs

Martino's Italian Beef And Hot Dogs
1215 W Layton Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53221 (Google Maps)

Martino's Italian Beef and Hot Dogs is a must-visit for anyone in search of a delicious Italian hoagie. The friendly staff creates a welcoming atmosphere, and the food is always fresh and tasty.

The menu offers a wide variety of options, including hot dogs, Italian beef, and chili dogs, all of which come with a generous serving of shoestring fries.

The prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal.

With a clean and efficient counter service, there's no need to wait long for your order. Don't forget to try their homemade cakes for a sweet treat!

5. Scardina Specialties

Scardina Specialties
715 E Locust St, Milwaukee, WI 53212 (Google Maps)

Scardina Specialties is a hidden gem for those searching for authentic Italian hoagies.

The deli panino is a must-try and the chicken Caesar wrap is loaded with chicken. Customers rave about the hot Italian beef sandwich and the homemade sausages.

The store is clean and has sit-down tables, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or dinner.

Don't forget to grab a cannoli for dessert. The friendly service and outstanding food make this place a must-visit in Milwaukee.

6. SALA

Sala
2613 E Hampshire St, Milwaukee, WI 53211 (Google Maps)

SALA is a cozy Italian spot that serves up delicious Sicilian pastas and pizzas. The red-walled, art-rich space is perfect for a romantic date or a night out with friends.

The patio is also a great option for outdoor dining. The hoagies are a must-try, with fresh ingredients and a flavorful taste that will leave your taste buds wanting more.

The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, making excellent recommendations. Prices are reasonable for the quality of food and service.

SALA is definitely worth a visit for anyone looking for a great Italian hoagie experience.

7. Hen's Deli

Hen's Deli
209 W Florida St, Milwaukee, WI 53204 (Google Maps)

Hen's Deli is the perfect spot for anyone in search of a delicious italian hoagie.

The bagels and sandwiches are made with creativity and care, which is evident in every bite.

The deli offers a range of options to choose from, but the italian hoagie is a standout. The bread is fresh and the ingredients are top-notch.

If you're in the mood for a tasty and satisfying meal, Hen's Deli is definitely worth a visit.

8. Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant

Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant
3468 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211 (Google Maps)

Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant is a must-visit for those craving authentic Italian hoagies.

The family-owned restaurant offers made-from-scratch meals that taste exactly like they're cooked in Italy. The lamb is a must-try and the portions are generous.

The restaurant has a warm and charming atmosphere, perfect for a date or a night out with friends.

The service is efficient and friendly, making the dining experience enjoyable from start to finish. Don't miss out on the opportunity to try Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant's delicious food.

9. Cafe La Scala

Cafe La Scala
631 E Chicago St, Milwaukee, WI 53202 (Google Maps)

Cafe La Scala is a must-visit for anyone in search of a delicious Italian hoagie. The take-out experience is efficient, with friendly staff and a quick turnaround time.

Their pizza is particularly noteworthy, with a taste that rivals that of an Italian family-owned restaurant.

While the menu is affordable, the quality of the food is not compromised. For a classier dinner date, the bright trattoria with a patio is a perfect setting.

Cafe La Scala offers casual Italian fare in a charming atmosphere, making it a great spot for pizza, burgers, pastas, and of course, Italian hoagies.

10. Filippo's Italian Restaurant

Filippo's Italian Restaurant
6915 W Lincoln Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53219 (Google Maps)

Looking for a delicious Italian hoagie in town, then head over to Filippo's Italian Restaurant. This cozy little place serves up authentic Sicilian cooking that will leave your taste buds wanting more.

From the fresh Italian bread to the rich sauce and toppings, their hoagies are a delight to savor.

The friendly staff and family-oriented atmosphere make the dining experience all the more enjoyable.

So, if you're in the mood for some hearty Italian fare, make sure to check out Filippo's Italian Restaurant.

11. Stella Van Buren

Stella Van Buren
550 N Van Buren St, Milwaukee, WI 53202 (Google Maps)

Stella Van Buren is an upscale Italian restaurant that serves delicious hoagies.

The restaurant is located in a posh hotel and has a great atmosphere. The menu has a variety of Italian dishes, steaks, and seafood.

The staff is knowledgeable and attentive, making the dining experience enjoyable. While the service may be slow, the quality of the food and drinks is worth the wait.

If you're looking for a high-end Italian restaurant to enjoy a hoagie, Stella Van Buren is a great option.

12. Barbiere's Italian Restaurant

Barbiere's Italian Restaurant
5844 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53213 (Google Maps)

Barbiere's Italian Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone in the mood for a delicious Italian hoagie.

This quaint little neighborhood restaurant offers a simple menu of pastas, salads, and pizzas, but their hoagies are truly exceptional. The portions are generous, and the ingredients are fresh and flavorful.

The service is friendly and fast, and the cozy atmosphere makes for a great dining experience. Be sure to try their famous garlic bread, which is a real star of the menu.

If you're looking for authentic Italian food that won't disappoint, look no further than Barbiere's Italian Restaurant.

13. Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Dom & Phil Demarinis Original Recipes
1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Looking for a great place to grab an Italian hoagie in Milwaukee that won't disappoint your taste buds and wallet alike?

Look no further than Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes. This family-owned pizzeria is a local favorite for its authentic Italian food and friendly service.

While they are known for their thin-crust pizzas and Friday night fish fry, their Italian hoagie is not to be missed.

Made with high-quality ingredients and served on fresh bread, it's the perfect sandwich for a quick lunch or a satisfying dinner.

Stop by and see why locals rave about this place!

14. Sal's Pizza East Side

Sal's Pizza East Side
2974 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211 (Google Maps)

Sal's Pizza East Side is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious Italian hoagies. Their menu features a wide selection of pizza types, and you can even order by the slice.

The new Sicilian deep dish pizza is a must-try, and on Tuesdays, you can take advantage of their buy one get one free offer.

The staff is friendly and the store is clean, making for a pleasant dining experience.

Don't forget to grab a complimentary garlic knot with every slice you buy. If you're in the mood for great pizza, Sal's Pizza East Side is the place to be.