Food & Drink

Mamma Mia! 16 Must-Try Pizza Places in Milwaukee

Milwaukee, Wisconsin is known for many things, but one of the most beloved foods in the city is pizza. Whether you're a fan of deep dish, thin crust, or something in between, there's a pizza place in Milwaukee that will satisfy your cravings.

With so many options to choose from, it can be overwhelming to decide where to go. That's where this guide comes in.

In this post, we'll be exploring some of the best pizza places in Milwaukee. From classic pizzerias to trendy new spots, we've got you covered.

We've scoured the city to find the most delicious pies, the friendliest staff, and the coziest atmospheres. Whether you're a local or just passing through, you won't want to miss out on these pizza hotspots.

Milwaukee's pizza scene is a reflection of the city's diverse culture and history. You'll find everything from traditional Italian-style pizzas to creative and innovative pies that push the boundaries of what pizza can be.

Many of the pizza places in Milwaukee use locally-sourced ingredients and have a commitment to sustainability and community. No matter what your preferences are, you're sure to find a pizza place in Milwaukee that will leave you feeling satisfied and happy. So without further ado, let's dive into the best pizza places in Milwaukee.

1. Santino's Little Italy

Santino's Little Italy
352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Santino's Little Italy is a rustic Italian restaurant that serves delicious Neapolitan style pizzas and pasta dishes. The cozy ambiance of the place gives off an old-school vibe that transports diners to Brooklyn in the 1890s.

The menu is small but the food is great, especially the crispy and flavorful pizzas cooked in an 800-degree oven.

The restaurant also offers a variety of drinks, including their house-made Sangria. The staff is friendly and accommodating, making the dining experience smooth and enjoyable.

It is highly recommended to make a reservation before visiting as the place is always busy. Santino's Little Italy is definitely worth a visit for those who love authentic Italian cuisine.

2. Tenuta's Italian Restaurant

Tenuta's Italian Restaurant
2995 S Clement Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Tenuta's Italian Restaurant is a cozy and quaint pizza place that serves up thin crust pizzas and homemade pastas.

With a decent selection of reasonably priced beers, it's a great spot for a casual night out.

The attentive service and fresh, delicious food make Tenuta's a must-try for anyone looking for classic Italian staples.

Don't miss out on the House Special pizza or the burrata appetizer. Reservations are recommended for busy nights.

3. Fixture Pizza Pub

Fixture Pizza Pub
623 S 2nd St, Milwaukee, WI 53204 (Google Maps)

Fixture Pizza Pub is a must-visit for pizza lovers. They offer a delicious gluten-free crust option, and their cheese is a standout ingredient.

In addition to great pizza, they have a fantastic selection of local beers on tap.

The wings are also a must-try, and the staff is friendly and attentive.

The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, perfect for a casual night out with friends or family. Don't miss out on this gem of a pizza place.

4. Transfer Pizzeria Cafe

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe
101 W Mitchell St, Milwaukee, WI 53204 (Google Maps)

Transfer Pizzeria Cafe is a relaxed cafe that offers over 40 types of creative pizzas, wine, beer, and live music.

They use fresh and locally-sourced ingredients, and are accommodating to food allergies.

Their garlic sauce, mushrooms, and sausage are highly recommended, and their crust is delicious. The atmosphere is inviting, with historic features and local art.

The service is friendly and professional, and the prices are reasonable. Transfer Pizzeria Cafe is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

5. Classic Slice

Classic Slice
2797 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Classic Slice is a must-visit pizza place for anyone in search of delicious and affordable pizza.

This counter-serve pizzeria offers gourmet pies and slices in a hip and casual space with arcade games. They have a variety of vegan options available, making it an ideal spot for everyone.

The crust is cracker-thin, and the sauce is not too sweet, making it a perfect balance of flavors. The service is quick, and the atmosphere is fun and lively.

Though there might be a wait during peak hours, the delicious pizza is worth it. Classic Slice is a great place to grab a slice, play some arcade games, and enjoy a fun night out.

6. San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203 (Google Maps)

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is a rustic-chic eatery that serves wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and antipasti.

The open kitchen adds to the atmosphere, and the service is excellent.

The Gnocchi is a must-have and the pizzas are delicious. The restaurant is perfect for a dinner before a show at Riverside.

The free limoncello at the end of the meal is a nice touch. The painting of San Giorgio is also very impressive.

7. Ned's Pizza

Ned's Pizza
3246 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53215 (Google Maps)

Ned's Pizza is a family-owned pizza spot that has been around since 1969.

They specialize in thin-crust pizza with a unique sauce that sets them apart from other pizza places in the area.

Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and are perfect for sharing with friends and family.

The staff is friendly and provides excellent customer service. If you're in the mood for a delicious pizza, Ned's Pizza is definitely worth checking out.

8. Calderone Club

Calderone Club
842 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203 (Google Maps)

Calderone Club is a must-visit pizza place for anyone who loves authentic Italian cuisine. With their thin-crust pies and made-from-scratch pasta, this restaurant is a haven for foodies who crave traditional Italian flavors.

The extensive wine list and custom craft cocktails make for the perfect accompaniment to the delicious food.

The old-world setting adds to the charm and makes for a cozy dining experience.

All in all, Calderone Club is a great choice for anyone looking for an Italian restaurant that offers a taste of Italy right in the heart of the city.

9. Sorella

2535 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Sorella is a gem of a pizza place with a relaxed ambiance that serves up Italian classics.

The pizza crust is chewy, soft, and perfectly cooked, making it a standout dish. The pasta and other Mediterranean staples are also worth trying.

The service is friendly and professional, and the staff is accommodating. The restaurant is cozy and comfortable, making it an excellent spot for a night out.

Don't forget to save room for dessert. The cheesecake is French-style, soft, and smooth, and absolutely delicious.

10. Wy'east Pizza

Wy'east Pizza
5601 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208 (Google Maps)

Wy'east Pizza serves up some of the best wood-fired pizza around.

The toppings are creative and work well together, and the crust has a nice chew around the edge and a great crisp underneath.

The pizza is worth every penny, and the customer service is excellent.

Highly recommended for pizza lovers.

11. Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar

Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar
1724 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202 (Google Maps)

Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar is a family-owned restaurant that has been serving delicious thin-crust pizza and Italian fare since 1954.

Customers rave about the crispy crust and generous toppings on the pizzas. The marinara sauce is sweet and savory, and the Italian sausage is juicy and flavorful.

The restaurant has a cozy bar and friendly waitstaff. The atmosphere is quintessentially Milwaukee. The menu also includes pasta dishes and salads.

Prices are reasonable, making it a great spot for a casual meal. Zaffiro's Pizza & Bar is a must-try for anyone who appreciates good pizza.

12. Milwaukee Classic Pizza

Milwaukee Classic Pizza
3929 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Google Maps)

Milwaukee Classic Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in town. Their crust is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with fresh ingredients that are always delicious.

The staff is friendly and the service is fast, whether you're dining in or taking out.

They also offer gluten-free and vegan options for those with dietary restrictions. Don't miss out on their gourmet pizzas and creative calzones, which are sure to satisfy any craving.

If you're looking for a great pizza place, Milwaukee Classic Pizza is definitely worth a visit.

13. Lisa's Pizzeria

Lisa's Pizzeria
2961 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211 (Google Maps)

Lisa's Pizzeria is an old-school parlor that has been serving up delicious pizza and classic Italian fare since 1960.

Their thin crust pizza is a must-try, with a variety of toppings to choose from.

The friendly staff provides quick service, whether you're dining in or getting carry-out.

Lisa's Pizzeria is a great spot to grab a tasty meal with family and friends.

14. State Street Pizza Pub

State Street Pizza Pub
322 W State St, Milwaukee, WI 53203 (Google Maps)

State Street Pizza Pub is a great spot to grab a slice and watch a game.

The customizable pizzas are delicious, and there's a good selection of tap beer.

The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is lively with plenty of TV screens.

It's a hidden gem that's definitely worth checking out.

15. Flourchild Pizza

Flourchild Pizza
722 N Milwaukee St, Milwaukee, WI 53202 (Google Maps)

Flourchild Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers. This pizza place offers unique and innovative flavors that are sure to impress.

The crust is perfect, and the toppings are delicious. The service is top-notch, and the staff is accommodating and attentive.

The ambiance is cool and fun, with lighthearted murals and a high ceiling giving a big, open feeling. The menu has some creative options and some takes on classics, so there is something for everyone.

The zucchini bites and wine list are both excellent. This pizza place is definitely worth checking out.

16. Cataro's Italian Villa

Cataro's Italian Villa
5641 Beloit Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53214 (Google Maps)

Cataro's Italian Villa is a neighborhood pizzeria that has been serving delicious pizzas for decades.

They offer both thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas with generous and flavorful toppings. The staff is friendly and hospitable, making the dining experience even more enjoyable.

Although the service can be slow during peak hours, the wait is worth it.

The prices are reasonable, making it a great place for a family dinner or a casual night out. It's no wonder Cataro's Italian Villa is a perennial parlor in the area.