Milwaukee may not be the first city that comes to mind when you think of lobster tails, but you'd be surprised at the number of places in the city that serve this delicious delicacy.
Whether you're a local or just visiting, finding the best places for lobster tails can be a daunting task. With so many options to choose from, it's hard to know which restaurants offer the freshest, most succulent lobster tails.
Luckily, we've done the research for you. We've scoured the city to find the best places for lobster tails, from upscale restaurants to casual eateries.
We've talked to locals, checked out online reviews, and tasted our fair share of lobster tails to bring you the top spots in Milwaukee.
If you're a seafood lover, you know that there's nothing quite like a perfectly cooked lobster tail. Whether you like it grilled, broiled, or baked, a good lobster tail should be tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor.
And while there are plenty of places in Milwaukee that offer lobster tails on their menus, not all of them are created equal. Some restaurants serve frozen lobster tails that have been shipped from faraway places, while others source their lobster locally and cook it to perfection on-site.
So, if you're ready to indulge in some of the best lobster tails that Milwaukee has to offer, keep reading.
Whether you're looking for a fancy night out or a casual meal with friends, we've got you covered. Get ready to savor the taste of Milwaukee's finest lobster tails.
1. The Capital Grille
The Capital Grille is a fine dining restaurant that offers some of the best lobster tail in town.
The lobster bisque is meaty and creamy, while the South African lobster is tender and melts in your mouth.
The lobster mac and cheese is full of flavor and the Kona rub bone-in NY dry-aged strip is cooked to perfection.
The service is knowledgeable and attentive, and the ambiance is elegant and inviting. The Capital Grille is the perfect place for a special occasion or a romantic night out.
2. St. Paul Fish Company
St. Paul Fish Company is a lively seafood spot that offers fresh and tasty lobster tail dishes at reasonable prices.
The restaurant is located inside a bustling food market and has a friendly staff that provides fast and attentive service.
While the seating area can be busy, the quality of the food makes it worth the wait. The lobster rolls and crab cakes are some of the best in the Midwest, and the oysters are a must-try.
If you're looking for a casual seafood eatery with great food, St. Paul Fish Company is definitely worth checking out.
3. Carnevor
Carnevor is a sleek and upscale steakhouse that also serves delicious lobster tail.
The atmosphere is dark and contemporary, making for a unique dining experience. The staff is hospitable and welcoming, and the service is exceptional.
The lobster tail is prepared to perfection and is definitely worth trying.
While the prices are on the higher end, the quality of the food and experience match it. If you're looking for a fancy night out, Carnevor is the place to go.
4. Five O'Clock Steakhouse
Five O'Clock Steakhouse is a classic supper club-style restaurant that has been serving up upscale steakhouse fare since 1946.
While their steaks are the star of the show, their lobster tail is not to be missed. The lobster tail is cooked to perfection and served with all the classic accompaniments.
The ambiance is old-school and cozy, making for a perfect dining experience. The service is top-notch and the staff is knowledgeable about the menu.
If you're looking for a classic steakhouse experience with some of the best lobster tail around, Five O'Clock Steakhouse is the place to be.
5. Buckley's Restaurant & Bar
Buckley's Restaurant & Bar is a neighborhood fixture that serves elevated American comfort food.
Their lobster tail is a must-try dish that is perfectly cooked and seasoned. The menu is inventive and offers unique dishes like truffle fried artichokes and fig tart.
The service is top-notch, and the atmosphere is cozy and welcoming. The wine list is extensive, and the cocktails are expertly crafted.
Buckley's is a great spot for a fine dining experience or a casual night out with friends.
6. Milwaukee Steakhouse
Milwaukee Steakhouse is a traditional dining venue that serves up classic American fare and seafood.
The Angus steaks are perfectly cooked and highly recommended. The lobster tail is a must-try, cooked to perfection and served with delicious sides.
The service is attentive and the atmosphere is comfortable. The restaurant is Covid-safe, with all staff wearing masks.
Parking is ample and reservations are easy to make. For a great dining experience, Milwaukee Steakhouse is a top choice.
7. Koi Japanese Cuisine
Koi Japanese Cuisine is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Their lobster tail is a must-try, cooked to perfection with a buttery flavor that melts in your mouth.
The sushi selection is also noteworthy, with fresh fish and creative rolls.
The service is friendly and attentive, making for a pleasant dining experience.
Though slightly pricier than other Japanese restaurants, the quality of the food justifies the cost. Koi Japanese Cuisine is a great spot for a special occasion or a date night.
8. Catfish Lounge
Catfish Lounge is a popular bar that serves delicious lobster tail.
Customers rave about the Sunday brunch featuring fried lobster tail, shrimp and grits, and chicken and waffles. The atmosphere is friendly and cozy, and the prices are great.
The staff is well-spoken and provides excellent customer service. The Catfish filet is the best in town, and the grits are perfectly seasoned.
The bar is known for its free pour drinks and good music. If you're looking for a fun and delicious place to enjoy lobster tail, Catfish Lounge is the place to be.
9. Mason Street Grill
Mason Street Grill is a classic steakhouse that offers more than just great steaks. Their lobster tail is a must-try for seafood lovers.
The atmosphere is elegant and perfect for a special occasion. The service is friendly and attentive, making the dining experience enjoyable.
Live jazz music adds to the ambience, making it a perfect spot for a night out. The prices are on the higher side, but the quality of food and service justifies the cost.
Mason Street Grill is a great place to indulge in a fine dining experience with delicious lobster tail.
10. Rare Steakhouse
Rare Steakhouse is a fine dining restaurant that serves up some of the best lobster tails in town.
The ambience is elegant and the service is top-notch. The menu features classic steakhouse favorites, but the seafood dishes are not to be missed.
The lobster tail is cooked to perfection, with a tender texture and a rich, buttery flavor. The sides are equally impressive, with options like crispy Brussels sprouts and creamy mac and cheese.
If you're looking for a special night out, Rare Steakhouse is the perfect spot for a luxurious meal.
11. Lowcountry Milwaukee
Lowcountry Milwaukee is a seafood and Cajun restaurant that serves some of the best lobster tail in town.
The food is delicious, and the service is excellent. The atmosphere is welcoming, with a fun and chill vibe that makes for a great dining experience.
The staff is friendly and helpful, and the prices are fair for the quality of food.
If you're looking for a place to enjoy some amazing seafood, Lowcountry Milwaukee is the place to be.
12. Milwaukee ChopHouse
Milwaukee ChopHouse is a classic chophouse that offers an extensive menu of seafood and steaks.
With its warm woods and white tablecloths, this restaurant exudes sophistication and elegance.
The lobster tail is a standout dish, cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. The attentive staff provides exceptional service, making for a memorable dining experience.
Milwaukee ChopHouse is the perfect place for a special occasion or a romantic night out.
13. The Packing House
The Packing House is a long-standing supper club that offers a variety of delicious seafood and steak dishes.
The lobster tail, in particular, is a must-try for seafood lovers. The atmosphere is elegant and welcoming, with live music on certain days of the week.
The service is prompt and attentive, making for an enjoyable dining experience. Prices are on the higher side, but the quality of the food and service make it worth the cost.
If you're looking for a classy night out with great seafood, The Packing House is a top choice.
14. Dream Dance Steakhouse
Dream Dance Steakhouse is an upscale casino restaurant that offers a fine dining experience. They specialize in steaks and lobster tail, and their 3-course meal is a great deal.
The staff is knowledgeable and friendly, and the atmosphere is fancy but not intimidating. The food is impeccable, and the bone-in ribeye is a must-try.
The wine list is extensive, with over 600 bottles to choose from. The restaurant also showcases Native American art.
It's a perfect place for a special occasion or a company holiday party. If you're looking for a great steak and lobster tail, Dream Dance Steakhouse is the place to be.
15. Brass Key Restaurant
If you're in the mood for some delicious lobster tail, Brass Key Restaurant is the place to be.
This family-owned and operated restaurant offers a wide selection of seafood and Greek dishes that will leave your taste buds craving for more.
The expert chef ensures that every dish is made to perfection, and the friendly and knowledgeable staff provides excellent service.
With reasonable prices, large portions, and a charming atmosphere, Brass Key Restaurant is the perfect spot for a delightful meal.
16. Red Crab – Juicy Seafood
If you're looking for a great place to satisfy your craving for seafood, Red Crab – Juicy Seafood is definitely worth checking out.
Their lobster tail is a standout dish, cooked to perfection with just the right amount of spice. The portions are generous and the flavor is top-notch.
The prices are reasonable and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. The atmosphere is fun and lively, making it a great spot to grab a bite to eat with friends or family.
Whether you're a seafood lover or just looking for a great meal, Red Crab – Juicy Seafood is definitely worth a visit.
